SOURCE SPECIES VEGTYPE EXPTYPE FIELD_POT FERTILIZER N_CONC_CON N_OBS_CON N_STD_CON N_CONC_TRT N_OBS_TRT N_STD_TRT LIG_CONC_CON LIG_OBS_CON LIG_STD_CON LIG_CONC_TRT LIG_OBS_TRT LIG_STD_TRT Arnone & Hirshel 1997 Carex curvula herb OTC field yes 15 4 2 12.8 4 2 91 4 10 89 4 10 Arnone & Hirshel 1997 Carex curvula herb OTC field no 12.8 12 1.732 11.8 12 1.732 80 12 8.66 78 12 8.66 Ball & Drake 1997 Spartina patens herb OTC field no 5.1 3 0.255 5.3 3 0.265 142 3 -999.99 144 3 -999.99 Ball & Drake 1998 Scirpus olneyi herb OTC field no 4.4 3 0.22 4 3 0.2 205 3 -999.99 205 3 -999.99 Cotrufo & Ineson 1996 Betula pendula woody SD pot no 11.8 6 1.8 8.8 6 1.7 177 6 43.2 287 6 48 Cotrufo & Ineson 1996 Betula pendula woody SD pot yes 16.3 6 1.6 16 6 1.5 133 6 25.8 170 6 21 Cotrufo et al. 1999 Quercus pubescens woody no-cham field no 13.8 3 0.7 14.2 3 0.7 194.3 3 4.9 267.7 3 14.7 De Angelis et al. 2000 Quercus ilex woody OTC field no 8.6 3 0.4 7.5 3 0.7 174.9 3 11.2 207.4 3 7 De Angelis et al. 2000 Phillyrea angustifolia woody OTC field no 10.7 3 0.6 9.3 3 0.7 161.1 3 9.4 178.2 3 5.2 De Angelis et al. 2000 Pistacia lentiscus woody OTC field no 11.1 3 0.2 9.6 3 0.6 159.2 3 8.5 185.9 3 10.5 De Angelis et al. 2000 Quercus ilex woody OTC field no 8.6 3 0.4 7.6 3 0.7 174.9 3 11.2 207.4 3 7 De Angelis et al. 2000 Phillyrea angustifolia woody OTC field no 10.2 3 0.6 9.5 3 0.7 161.1 3 9.4 178.2 3 5.2 De Angelis et al. 2000 Pistacia lentiscus woody OTC field no 11.1 3 0.2 9.9 3 0.6 159.2 3 8.5 185.9 3 10.5 Dukes & Field 2000 C3 grassland mixture herb OTC pot no 3.4 6 0.245 3.8 6 0.49 70 6 19.596 58 6 14.697 Dukes & Field 2000 C3 grassland mixture herb OTC pot no 4.2 6 0.49 4.2 6 0.245 59 5 17.889 60 5 13.416 Finzi et al. 2000 Cercis canadensis woody no-cham field no 10.14 3 0.87 10.02 3 2.08 177 2 16.97 169.5 2 7.78 Finzi et al. 2000 Cornus florida woody no-cham field no 9 3 0.35 6.7 3 0.69 -999.9 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Finzi et al. 2000 Acer rubrum woody no-cham field no 7.264 3 0.52 6.573 3 0.52 138.3 3 23.03 129.7 3 12.9 Finzi et al. 2000 Liquidambar styraciflua woody no-cham field no 6.708 3 0.52 6.323 3 0.69 136.7 3 17.93 146.7 3 3.76 Finzi et al. 2000 Pinus taeda woody no-cham field no 4.7 3 0.17 4.9 3 0.17 209 3 4.58 212.7 3 8.02 Finzi et al. 2000 Cercis canadensis woody no-cham field no 11.4 3 0.17 11.4 3 2.6 177 2 16.97 169.5 2 7.78 Finzi et al. 2000 Cornus florida woody no-cham field no 7.1 3 2.42 7.1 3 0.69 -999.9 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Finzi et al. 2000 Acer rubrum woody no-cham field no 7 3 0.87 7 3 1.04 138.3 3 23.03 129.7 3 12.9 Finzi et al. 2000 Liquidambar styraciflua woody no-cham field no 6.4 3 0.87 6.4 3 0.52 136.7 3 17.93 146.7 3 3.76 Finzi et al. 2000 Pinus taeda woody no-cham field no 4.9 3 0.52 5 3 0.17 209 3 4.58 212.7 3 8.02 Gahrooee 1998 Quercus cerris woody no-cham field no 7.3 2 0.1 7.2 2 0.2 253 2 19.6 272 2 15.5 Gahrooee 1998 Quercus pubescens woody no-cham field no 8 2 0.1 8.1 2 0.2 207 2 17.2 193 2 27.4 Hättenschwiler et al. 1999 Fagus sylvatica woody OTC field no 12.5 4 1.4 10.6 4 1 116 4 13 121 4 16 Hirshel et al. 1997 Carex curvula herb OTC field no 12.9 12 1.386 11.6 12 0.4 80.6 12 10.046 77 12 6.582 Hirshel et al. 1997 graminoid mixture herb no-cham field no 10.9 8 1.131 10.6 8 2.546 75.8 8 11.314 76.9 8 5.374 Hirshel et al. 1997 Carex flacca herb no-cham field no 9.2 8 1.414 9.5 8 1.414 105 8 11.314 104 8 11.314 Ineson et al. 1999 Rubus chamaemorus woody SD pot no 16.2 1 -999.99 13.8 1 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Kemp et al. 1994 Andropogon gerardii herb OTC field no 3.9 5 0.29 4.2 5 0.27 148 5 11.2 151 5 11.2 Kemp et al. 1994 Andropogon gerardii herb OTC field yes 3.9 5 0.22 4.2 5 0.13 148 5 6.7 151 5 8.9 Kemp et al. 1994 Sorghastrum nutans herb OTC field no 3.9 5 0.49 4 5 0.25 127 5 6.7 125 5 2.2 Kemp et al. 1994 Sorghastrum nutans herb OTC field yes 3.4 5 0.34 2.4 5 0.13 124 5 8.9 129 5 2.2 Kemp et al. 1994 Poa pratensis herb OTC field no 12.1 5 0.67 10.4 5 0.2 116 5 8.9 109 5 8.9 Kemp et al. 1994 Poa pratensis herb OTC field yes 12.3 5 0.45 9.4 5 0.25 118 5 4.5 114 5 6.7 Rey & Jarvis 1998 Betula pendula woody OTC field no 6.4 1 -999.99 7.4 1 -999.99 23 1 -999.99 26.5 1 -999.99 Norby et al. 2000 Acer rubrum woody OTC field no 7.6 3 0.66 5.9 3 1 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Norby et al. 2000 Acer rubrum woody OTC field no 8.3 3 0.22 7.1 3 1.46 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Norby et al. 2000 Acer saccharum woody OTC field no 6.7 3 0.97 5.5 3 0.52 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Norby et al. 2000 Acer saccharum woody OTC field no 6.7 3 0.79 5.4 3 0.03 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Norby et al. 2000 Acer rubrum woody OTC field no 7.1 3 0.3 6.2 3 0.45 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Norby et al. 2000 Acer rubrum woody OTC field no 9.6 3 0.8 9.7 3 1.81 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Norby et al. 2000 Acer saccharum woody OTC field no 7.2 3 0.33 7.4 3 0.7 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Norby et al. 2000 Acer saccharum woody OTC field no 10.5 3 2.2 9.7 3 0.77 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Norby 1996 Quercus alba woody OTC field no 10 2 1.2 9.2 2 3.2 136 2 10 140 2 2 Norby 1996 Quercus alba woody OTC field no 10.3 2 0.5 9.8 2 0.3 150 2 3 152 2 2 Norby 1996 Quercus alba woody OTC field no 10.3 1 -999.99 10.1 1 -999.99 152 1 -999.99 161 1 -999.99 Norby 1996 Quercus alba woody OTC field no 11 5 1.3 10 5 2 162 5 11 155 5 17 Norby et al. 1995 Liriodendron tulipifera woody OTC field no 10.8 1 -999.99 9.6 1 -999.99 176 1 -999.99 160 1 -999.99 Norby et al. 1995 Liriodendron tulipifera woody OTC field no 11.1 4 5 10.8 4 1.8 180 1 -999.99 182 1 -999.99 Strand et al. 1999 Quercus rubra woody OTC field no 15.5 4 1.26 14.9 4 0.38 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Strand et al. 1999 Betula papyrifera woody OTC field no 12.7 4 0.64 17 4 0.61 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Strand et al. 1999 Betula papyrifera woody OTC field no 12.5 4 1.04 10.9 4 0.44 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Hungate et al. 1997 serpentine mixture herb OTC field no 9.7 10 0.949 9.7 10 1.581 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Hungate et al. 1997 sandstone mixture herb OTC field no 7.4 10 0.632 7.4 10 1.265 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 El Kohen et al. 1992 Castanea sativa woody OTC pot no 8.8 1 -999.99 9.8 1 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 El Kohen et al. 1992 Castanea sativa woody OTC pot yes 6.3 20 1.1 6.3 20 0.9 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Curtis et al. 1989 Scirpus olneyi herb OTC field no 5.7 5 0.7 5.5 5 0.8 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Curtis et al. 1989 Scirpus olneyi herb OTC field no 10 5 2.5 9.1 5 1.4 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Randlett et al. 1996 Populus x euramericana woody OTC field no 19.4 5 4 14.4 5 2.6 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Johnson et al. 2001 Liquidambar styraciflua woody no-cham field no 9.4 3 0.68 9.2 2 0.84 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Johnson et al. 2001 Liquidambar styraciflua woody no-cham field no 8.3 3 0.13 7.4 2 0.29 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Vogel et al. 1997 Alnus glutinosa woody OTC field yes 20.8 5 1.14 18.9 5 0.94 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Sowerby et al. 2000 Holcus lanatus herb no-cham field no 17.9 6 1.25 16 6 0.85 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Sowerby et al. 2000 Pennisetum clandestirum herb no-cham field no 31 6 1.04 23.1 6 0.5 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Cotrufo et al. 1994 Fraxinus excelsior woody SD pot no 11.4 2 2.3 8.4 2 1.2 61 2 0.7 74 2 12.7 Cotrufo et al. 1994 Betula pubescens woody SD pot no 14 2 1.4 9.4 2 0.8 135 2 35.4 160 2 -999.99 Cotrufo et al. 1994 Acer pseudoplatanus woody SD pot no 5.7 2 0.2 4.6 2 0.4 91 2 11.3 98 2 3.5 Johnson et al. 2000 Pinus ponderosa woody OTC field no 4.43 9 0.83 3.28 9 0.45 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Johnson et al. 2000 Pinus ponderosa woody OTC field yes 2.88 9 0.27 3.33 9 0.03 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99 Johnson et al. 2000 Pinus ponderosa woody OTC field yes 3.47 9 0.48 3.65 9 0.24 -999.99 0 -999.99 -999.99 0 -999.99