|
Agenda
Conference Chair: Russell Lee, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
Conference Facilitator: Douglas R. Brookman, Public Solutions, Inc.
[ Monday, March 4 ] [ Tuesday, March 5 ]
Monday, March 4, 2002
| Time |
Session |
|
7:15 - 8:00 |
Continental breakfast |
|
8:00 - 8:45 |
-
1. Conference Opening, Overview, Background, and Objectives
-
 Russell Lee, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
- C. Michael Smith, Office of Fossil Energy, U.S. Department of Energy
- Loretta Beaumont, U.S. House of Representatives Interior Appropriations Staff
|
|
8:45 - 9:30 |
-
2. Methods Currently Used by DOE Offices to Estimate the Benefits of Their R&D Programs
- Mary Beth Zimmerman, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, DOE
- Jay Braitsch, Office of Fossil Energy, DOE
- Trevor L. Cook Office of Nuclear Energy, Science, and Technology, DOE
- Robert Vallario, Office of Science, DOE
|
|
9:30 - 10:15 |
-
3. Federal Perspectives on Performance Measurement
- Jeanne Powell, Advanced Technology Program,
 National Institute of Standards and Technology
- Robert Pearce, Office of Aerospace Technology,
National Aeronautical and Space Administration
- Robert C. Ricci, Volpe National Transportation Systems Center,
U.S. Department of Transportation
- Mark A. Weatherly, Office of Management and Budget
|
|
10:15 - 10:30 |
Break |
|
10:30 - 11:00 |
-
4. Establishing a Starting Point for Discussion of a Methodological Framework
for Defining R&D Benefits
- National Research Council Framework for Defining the Benefits of R&D
- Robert Fri, Resources for the Future
- James L. Sweeney, Stanford University
- Building on the Framework
- Russell Lee, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
|
|
11:00 - 11:15 |
5. Structure, Goals, and Priorities of the Workshops
Douglas R. Brookman, Public Solutions, Inc.
|
|
11:15 - 12:15 |
Workshop A:
Prospective Benefits -- Cross-Cutting Issues |
Workshop B:
Option Value |
Workshop C:
Knowledge Value |
Workshop D:
Security, Economic, and Environmental Benefits |
-
· Facilitator, Day 1:
Lisa Frantzis,
AD Little
· Rapporteur, Day 1:
James L. Wolf,
Independent
Consultant
|
-
· Facilitator, Day 1:
Nalin Kulatilaka,
Boston University
· Rapporteur, Day 1:
Brandon Owens,
National Renewable
Energy Laboratory
|
-
· Facilitator, Day 1:
Susan E. Cozzens,
Georgia Institute of
Technology
· Rapporteur, Day 1:
Gretchen Jordan,
Sandia National
Laboratories
|
-
· Facilitator, Day 1:
Rachel Winters,
NYSERDA
· Rapporteur, Day 1:
Paul Leiby,
Oak Ridge National
Laboratory
|
|
A1. Framework for defining the benefits of R&D programs, and its use for GPRA and R&D planning and evaluation |
B1. Framework for defining the benefits of R&D programs, and its use for GPRA and R&D planning and evaluation |
C1. Framework for defining the benefits of R&D programs, and its use for GPRA and R&D planning and evaluation |
D1. Framework for defining the benefits of R&D programs, and its use for GPRA and R&D planning and evaluation |
|
|
12:15 - 1:30 |
Luncheon and Keynote Address
William D. Magwood, IV, Director, Office of Nuclear Energy, Science, and Technology,
U.S. Department of Energy
|
|
1:30 - 2:30 |
-
6. Summaries and Feedback on the Workshops' Discussions of a Benefits Framework
- James L. Wolf, Independent Consultant
- Brandon Owens, National Renewable Energy Laboratory
- Gretchen Jordan, Sandia National Laboratories
- Paul Leiby, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
|
|
2:30 - 4:00 |
Workshop A:
Prospective Benefits -- Cross-Cutting Issues |
Workshop B:
Option Value |
Workshop C:
Knowledge Value |
Workshop D:
Security, Economic, and Environmental Benefits |
|
A2. Defining and calculating the projected baseline on which new technologies are to be introduced |
B2. Definition of options and the calculation of option value |
C2. Definition of knowledge value and indicators |
D2. Security benefits of R&D on energy technologies and systems |
-
· Frances Wood,
OnLocation
· James Turnure,
ICF Consulting
· Robert L. Hirsch,
RAND
|
-
· John J. Wise,
retired and formerly
with Mobil Research
and Development
Company
· Graham Davis,
Colorado School
of Mines
· Soussan Faiz,
Independent
Consultant
· Gregory L. Hamm,
Independent
Consultant
|
-
· Irwin Feller,
The Pennsylvania
State University
· Diana Hicks,
CHI
|
-
· David L. Greene,
Oak Ridge
National Laboratory
· John Stringer,
EPRI
· Paula L. Scalingi,
The Scalingi Group
· Marjorie L. Tatro,
Sandia National
Laboratories
|
|
|
4:00 - 4:15 |
Break |
|
4:15 - 5:30 |
Workshop A:
Prospective Benefits -- Cross-Cutting Issues |
Workshop B:
Option Value |
Workshop C:
Knowledge Value |
Workshop D:
Security, Economic, and Environmental Benefits |
|
A3. Continued discussion of projected baseline |
B3. Continued discussion of option value |
C3. Continued discussion of knowledge value |
D3. Continued discussion of security benefits |
|
|
5:30 - 7:00 |
Reception |
|
7:00 on |
Dinner and keynote Address
Joseph S. Wholey, University of Southern California |
Tuesday, March 5, 2002
| Time |
Session |
|
7:15 - 8:00 |
Continental breakfast |
|
8:00 - 9:00 |
-
7. Review the First Day's Workshops and Review of the Second Day of Workshops
- James L. Wolf, Independent Consultant
- Brandon Owens, National Renewable Energy Laboratory
- Gretchen Jordan, Sandia National Laboratories
- Paul Leiby, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
|
|
9:00 - 10:30 |
|
Workshop A:
Prospective Benefits -- Cross-Cutting Issues |
Workshop B:
Option Value |
Workshop C:
Knowledge Value |
Workshop D:
Security, Economic, and Environmental Benefits |
-
· Facilitator, Day 2:
Lisa Frantzis,
AD Little
· Rapporteur, Day 2:
James L. Wolf,
Independent
Consultant
|
-
· Facilitator, Day 2:
Dennis Clough,
Aspen Systems
· Rapporteur, Day 2:
Brandon Owens,
National Renewable
Energy Laboratory
|
-
· Facilitator, Day 2:
Susan E. Cozzens,
Georgia Institute of
Technology
· Rapporteur, Day 2:
Gretchen Jordan,
Sandia National
Laboratories
|
-
· Facilitator, Day 2:
Gunnar Walmet,
NYSERDA
· Rapporteur, Day 2:
Paul Leiby,
Oak Ridge National
Laboratory
|
|
A4. The effect of a government's R&D program on technology deployment and use |
B4. The baseline scenario for option-value calculations |
C4. The baseline scenario for knowledge-value calculations |
D4. Economic benefits of R&D on energy technologies and systems |
-
· Ric Cheston,
General Accounting
Office
· Thomas Pelsoci,
Delta Research Co.
· Rosalie Ruegg,
TIA Consulting
|
Selected participants from Workshop A will join this session |
Selected participants from Workshop A will join this session |
-
· Molly Kenna
Macauley,
Resources for
the Future
· M. Ishaq Nadiri,
New York University
|
|
|
10:30 - 10:45 |
Break |
|
10:45 - 12:15 |
|
Workshop A:
Prospective Benefits -- Cross-Cutting Issues |
Workshop B:
Option Value |
Workshop C:
Knowledge Value |
Workshop D:
Security, Economic, and Environmental Benefits |
|
A5. Continued discussion of the effect of a government's R&D program on technology deployment and use |
B5. Effect of a government's R&D programs on option value |
C5. Effect of a government's R&D programs on knowledge value |
D5. Environmental benefits of R&D on energy technologies and systems |
|
|
Selected participants from Workshop A will join this session |
Selected participants from Workshop A will join this session |
-
· Michael McKee,
University of
New Mexico
· Robert Costanza,
University of
Maryland
|
|
|
12:15 - 1:30 |
-
Luncheon and Keynote Address
- David K. Garman, Assistant Secretary, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy,
U.S. Department of Energy
|
|
1:30 - 3:00 |
|
Workshop A:
Prospective Benefits -- Cross-Cutting Issues |
Workshop B:
Option Value |
Workshop C:
Knowledge Value |
Workshop D:
Security, Economic, and Environmental Benefits |
|
A6. Using estimates of benefits in R&D program planning and evaluation |
B6. Using estimates of benefits in R&D program planning and evaluation |
C6. Using estimates of benefits in R&D program planning and evaluation |
D6. Using estimates of benefits in R&D program planning and evaluation |
-
· John Mortensen,
Consultant
· Helen Kim,
NYSERDA
|
-
· Scott H. Mathews,
Boeing Phantom
Works
· Steffan Gackstatter,
AD Little
|
-
· J. David Roessner,
SRI International
· Parry M. Norling,
Dupont and RAND
|
-
· Scott W. Tinker,
University of Texas
· John Stringer,
EPRI
|
|
|
3:00 - 3:15 |
Break |
|
3:15 - 4:15 |
-
8. Workshop Summaries and Discussion
- James L. Wolf, Independent Consultant
- Brandon Owens, National Renewable Energy Laboratory
- Gretchen Jordan, Sandia National Laboratories
- Paul Leiby, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
|
|
4:15 - 4:30 |
-
9. Next Steps and Closing Remarks
- Russell Lee, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
|
If you have any questions, please contact:
Ms. Stephanie Floyd
Oak Ridge National Laboratory
P.O. Box 2008, Oak Ridge, TN 37831-6207
Phone: 865-574-5517; Fax: 865-574-8272; E-mail: floydsd@ornl.gov
or
Russell Lee
Phone: 865-576-6818; Fax: 865-574-8272; E-mail: leerm@ornl.gov |
